Praying mantis in NZ: the native mantis and the South African arrival
A green mantis resting on a leaf with its forelegs folded is one of the more recognisable small creatures in a New Zealand garden. What most people do not realise is that there are two kinds, and only one of them belongs here. The other came from southern Africa within living memory and is slowly spreading through the country.
The native: Orthodera novaezealandiae
The New Zealand mantis, Orthodera novaezealandiae, is indigenous and found only here. It is widely distributed in both islands. It is smaller than the African species and is usually green, only very rarely yellow. The area between its front legs is as wide as its head, and tapers gradually to the waist. The clearest mark is a bright blue and purple patch on the inside of the front legs. It can fly, and it is usually found on the upper side of leaves. Its egg case is neat, darker and compact, and it does not overwinter, and females rarely eat the male after mating (Travis Wetland Trust).
The newcomer: Miomantis caffra
The South African, or springbok, mantis, Miomantis caffra, is native to southern Africa. The first specimens were nymphs collected by an Auckland schoolboy at his New Lynn home in February 1978, and researchers think the species arrived as egg cases on plant material or cargo (Wikipedia: Miomantis caffra).
Adults are about 32 to 60 mm long, usually pale green or brown, sometimes with pink or purplish colouring at the base of the forewing, and the hind wings green or bright yellow. Males are smaller and more slender than females, with longer antennae (Wikipedia). The body section between the first two pairs of legs is narrower than the head, and it lacks the blue and purple patch on the front legs. Females cannot fly, though males fly short distances. It usually lurks on the underside of leaves, and it can overwinter in warmer climates (Travis Wetland Trust).
How to tell them apart
- Inside of the front legs. A bright blue and purple patch means the native mantis. No patch means the South African species.
- Body shape. The region behind the head is as wide as the head in the native mantis and narrower than the head in the South African one.
- Size and colour. The native is smaller and green; the South African species is often larger and ranges from green to pale brown.
- Where on the leaf. Native mantis on top of leaves, South African mantis lurking underneath.
- Egg cases. The native's case is neat, dark and compact. The South African egg case looks like foam when laid, often with a bluish tinge and drawn-out ends. Egg cases are roughly 12 to 30 mm long and have a handle-like extension at one end, and they are hardy enough to survive winter in cold parts of New Zealand (Wikipedia).
Sexing either species is possible by counting abdominal segments: females generally have six and males eight.
What has happened since 1978
Travis Wetland's account says the African species has gradually spread south, apparently displacing the native one. It is not widely distributed in the South Island but is established around Nelson and has been reported at Lyttelton, and it is not known from Travis Wetland itself, where a native population lives (Travis Wetland Trust).
One reason concerns mating. University of Auckland research found that native males approached invasive females in a Y-shaped maze more than 80 per cent of the time, which suggests the two species may share pheromones. When males and females were put together, South African females ate nearly 40 per cent of their own males and nearly 70 per cent of native males. Wikipedia summarises it as sexual cannibalism that may contribute to the native's displacement in urban areas of northern New Zealand (Wikipedia).
The South African mantis is not considered a pest, and nothing in these sources suggests it harms people or plants.
What to do if you find one
If you want to look more closely, turn over a front leg gently or photograph it, since the blue and purple patch settles the question. Egg cases on fences, plant stems and eaves are another way to check what has been breeding in your garden.
Whether to leave a South African mantis alone is a matter of taste; the sources reviewed give no instruction either way.
Nymphs and egg cases
Young mantises, called nymphs, vary widely in colour, from pale straw through bright green to reddish brown, so colour alone is a poor guide at that stage. South African nymphs are cannibalistic and will eat siblings even when other prey is available. Hatching from a single egg case is staggered and can stretch over weeks, or even two seasons, and the cases are hardy enough to survive winter in cold parts of New Zealand, including alpine areas. Females can also reproduce without mating, which helps a newly arrived female start a population (Wikipedia).
Seeing them in the garden
Mantises are ambush hunters that wait, folded and still, for prey to come within reach, which is why they are easy to walk past. The native species can be found on the upper side of leaves, so a mantis in plain view on top of a leaf points towards Orthodera, while one hiding under a leaf points towards the African species. These are tendencies, not rules, so check the legs as well.
Both species also have a place in the garden food web. Neither is described as a pest, and the South African mantis is explicitly said not to be considered one (Wikipedia).